
Key Takeaways
Whenever the open office gets criticised, and it has been criticised heavily, activity based working turns up as the answer. Give people a range of settings, let them move between those settings according to the task, and the focus problem solves itself. We made a version of that argument ourselves when we asked whether the open office layout is still relevant.
The model deserves the same scrutiny the open office received. Open plan was also evidence-backed when it was introduced, also framed as the obvious next step, and also rolled out at scale before anyone had measured what it did to the people inside it.
This article puts activity based working through that examination. What problem it was built to solve, whether the research actually supports it, the strongest argument against it, and the conditions under which it is worth the disruption. There is a verdict at the end, though it is a conditional one.
What problem was activity based working meant to solve?
Activity based working was designed to resolve a genuine contradiction between two failing models: assigned desks that sat empty, and open plan floors where nobody could concentrate. The proposal was to stop assigning desks, build several distinct types of space instead, and let employees pick the setting that matched the task in front of them.
The logic is sound on paper. Focused work goes in an enclosed room, calls go in a booth, collaboration goes in an open zone, and nobody pays rent on a desk that is occupied twice a week.
Each of the three models made a promise. It is worth setting the promises next to what the research subsequently found.
| Model |
The promise |
What the evidence showed |
| Assigned desks |
Everyone has exactly what they need, always |
Occupancy stays low across the week, so cost per used desk climbs |
| Open plan |
Remove walls, unlock spontaneous collaboration |
Face-to-face interaction fell roughly 70% at two Fortune 500 firms after the switch (HBR) |
| Activity based working |
The right setting for every task, chosen freely |
44% still pick a space based on availability rather than fit (Gensler) |
That bottom row is the uncomfortable one. If people are choosing on availability, the model is delivering hot desking with a longer walk.
Does the research support activity based working, or does it support choice?
The strongest evidence usually cited in favour of activity based working measures something slightly different: employee agency. Gensler found that people with high autonomy over where and how they work are around 2.5 times more likely to say their workspace supports productivity, and nearly three times more likely to call their office a great place to work.
Agency is the variable doing the work in those numbers, and activity based working is one way of delivering agency among several. Letting someone work from home on a call-heavy day delivers agency. Flexible hours deliver agency. A quiet assigned desk in a building with enough meeting rooms delivers agency, at considerably lower project cost.
The gap between "choice improves outcomes" and "therefore rebuild the floor plan" is wider than most business cases acknowledge. Activity based working delivers agency only when the preferred setting is genuinely obtainable at the moment it is needed, and it removes agency when it is not, because the assigned desk it replaced was at least guaranteed.
Gartner's finding that onsite and hybrid employees were rated highly productive at an identical 21% points the same direction. Physical arrangement moves the needle less than the workplace industry, ourselves included, tends to claim.
Has decades of layout redesign actually made offices work better?
Gensler’s conclusion that space effectiveness for most work modes has not fundamentally improved since 2008 covers the entire era of open plan, hot desking, agile working, and activity-based design.
- Widespread Workspace Hacking: The 2026 Global Workplace Survey, covering 16,459 office workers across 16 countries, found that two-thirds of employees report hacking their workspace to compensate for shortcomings.
- Improvised Fixes: One in four employees have improvised their own ergonomic or privacy fixes, bringing in headphones, monitors, screens, and signs because the space does not do the job.
- Persistent Issues: Availability and noise remain the primary obstacles. These are identified as operational problems rather than purely architectural ones—revolving around whether the right space exists in sufficient quantity and can be found when needed.
Is activity based working the open office with better vocabulary?
This is the sharpest objection, and it deserves an honest hearing before any rebuttal. Both models remove assigned territory. Both rely on employees behaving differently once their personal space is taken away. Both were sold with a collaboration narrative and costed with a real estate spreadsheet.
The Harvard Business Review finding matters here more than it usually gets credit for. Face-to-face interaction collapsed in those two firms because removing privacy and ownership changed how willing people were to speak in front of colleagues, and they retreated to messaging instead. Activity based working removes ownership too, so assuming the behavioural risk disappears because the space is nicer would be optimistic.
The defensible difference comes down to one testable condition: whether the enclosed settings genuinely exist in sufficient number, and whether an employee can get into one within a couple of minutes of deciding they need it. Meet that condition and activity based working is meaningfully different from open plan. Miss it and the two are the same building with different signage.
That gives you a falsification test most rollouts never run. Count the focus rooms and call booths. Divide by peak day headcount. If the ratio is below roughly one enclosed seat per ten people on the floor, the model will not hold, whatever the mood boards promised.
What has to be true before an activity based office delivers anything?
Five conditions, and the model degrades quickly when any one of them is missing. None are about furniture.
- Enough enclosed space. Focus rooms and call booths are the settings that determine whether people trust the office. They are also the settings most often cut when the budget tightens.
- Real-time visibility of what is free. People choose on availability when availability is invisible. This is the condition that converts theoretical choice into actual choice.
- Booked space that is actually occupied. Ghost bookings make a floor look full in the system and empty in reality, which corrupts every capacity decision you make afterwards.
- Written rules. Activity based working multiplies the number of unwritten social norms in a building. Gartner found employees are 12% more likely to leave where employers do not establish explicit hybrid work norms, and the same logic applies to rules about who can occupy which zone.
- Employee involvement before the move. Gartner also found three quarters of digital workers want to participate in creating their hybrid work model. A floor plan announced by email begins with a credibility problem.
Conditions two and three are where the technology question sits, and plenty of organisations plan an entire move without knowing that layer is available to them. The floor gets designed, the ratios get agreed and the date gets set, and only afterwards does anyone ask how a person walking onto level three will actually see what is free.
Door Tablet helps address these challenges by showing real-time room availability on displays outside meeting spaces, making it easier for employees to find somewhere suitable to work. Its hot-desking and check-in features help prevent unused reservations from blocking valuable space, while wayfinding helps employees locate available rooms. Utilisation reporting also gives facilities teams the information they need to understand how spaces are being used and plan accordingly.
Knowing that at the planning stage changes the ratios you set, because you can size the floor against what people actually claim rather than what they book.
Read about all the tech you need in order to deploy activity based spaces
When is activity based working worth it, and when is it not?
It is worth it for organisations with varied task profiles, low peak occupancy and enough floor area to build genuine setting variety. It is a poor fit for small teams, uniform work, or any project where the cost saving is the only real objective.
| Your situation |
Verdict |
Why |
| Peak attendance well below desk count, mixed task types, multiple floors |
Strong case |
Variety is affordable and the desk saving funds the enclosed settings |
| Single floor, roughly 40 people or fewer |
Weak case |
Informal finding already works, and the technology overhead outweighs the gain |
| Attendance concentrated on two or three predictable days |
Mixed |
Peak day sizing dominates, so the desk saving may be smaller than modelled |
| Fixed equipment, regulated roles, or accessibility requirements |
Poor fit |
Build assigned exceptions in from the start rather than negotiating them later |
| Cost reduction is the primary driver |
Poor fit |
Desks get cut, the enclosed settings never get built, and you arrive at open plan |
The last row is the common failure, and it rarely announces itself. The saving gets taken at the start of the project and the focus rooms get value engineered out at the end.
FAQ's
Is activity based working better than an open plan office?
It can be, provided the enclosed settings are genuinely built and genuinely available. Activity based working without adequate focus and call space produces the same conditions as open plan, so the comparison depends entirely on execution rather than on the model.
What are the main pros and cons of activity based working?
The main advantages are real estate efficiency, task-appropriate settings and increased employee agency where the model is properly resourced. The main disadvantages are the loss of a guaranteed seat, a heavier reliance on booking systems and social norms, and a tendency for enclosed spaces to be cut from the budget.
Do we need activity based working if attendance is already low?
Low attendance strengthens the financial case and says nothing about whether people will work better. Treat the desk saving and the productivity claim as two separate arguments, and require evidence for each.
How many enclosed spaces does an activity based office need?
A working starting point is one enclosed seat, meaning a focus room or call booth, per ten people on the floor at peak. Test that ratio against your own utilisation data rather than adopting it as a standard.
How would we know if it was not working?
Set the failure criteria before you move. Track no-show rates, utilisation by setting type, and a survey question about ability to do focused work, and compare all three against a baseline captured before any change.
So do we actually need activity based working?
Some organisations do, and a good many have adopted it because the alternative had been discredited rather than because the model fitted them. The research supports giving people genuine choice over how they work. It does not, on its own, support any particular floor plan as the way to deliver that choice.
The more useful question for most facilities and IT teams is narrower. Can you provide enough enclosed space, make availability visible in real time, and enforce the rules that keep both intact? Answer yes to all three and activity based working will probably repay the disruption. Answer no to any one of them and the honest option is to fix availability and noise in the office you already have, which is where the evidence has been pointing since 2008.
Workplace models come with a persuasive story attached. The measurement is what survives contact with the building.